Values by metric family

Each value as the document printed it. Select a value for its source, its checks and its history. Values from other documents are listed after the model’s own, each marked as the first report of that measure or as a restatement.

KeyVerifiedUnverifiedDisputedCorrected read off a figure or stated in wordsA value opens its source and history.

M1 · Evaluation awareness 4 values

M1 Evaluation awareness: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Evaluation awarenessVerbalized eval awareness, broadCondition: all samplesRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Evaluation awarenessVerbalized eval awareness, broadCondition: scheming samplesRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Evaluation awarenessVerbalized eval awareness, strictCondition: all samplesRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Evaluation awarenessVerbalized eval awareness, strictCondition: scheming samplesRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M3 · Sabotage and sandbagging 1 value

M3 Sabotage and sandbagging: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Sandbagging reviewClear evidence of sandbaggingRun by METRGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M4 · Misalignment audits 3 values

M4 Misalignment audits: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Covert deceptive behaviorShare of trajectories with deceptive actionCondition: Apollo scheming suiteRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Log falsificationCovert action rateCondition: strong goal nudgeRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Log falsificationCovert action rateCondition: weak goal nudgeRun by Apollo ResearchGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M5 · Honesty and hallucination 8 values

M5 Honesty and hallucination: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
AbstentionBenchRecall (appropriate abstention)GPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Deception evalAgentic coding (impossible tasks)GPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Deception evalBrowsing broken toolsGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Deception evalCharXiv missing imageGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production CoT deception monitorShare of responses flagged deceptiveCondition: representative production trafficGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production-traffic factualityClaim-level hallucination rate reduction vs o3Condition: with browsing; production promptsGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production-traffic factualityReduction in responses with 1+ major error vs o3Condition: with browsing; production promptsGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
SimpleQAHallucination rateCondition: no browsingGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M6 · Sycophancy 1 value

M6 Sycophancy: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Sycophancy offline evalSycophancy scoreCondition: offlineGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M7 · Harmful compliance and over-refusal 26 values

M7 Harmful compliance and over-refusal: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksExtremismGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksHarassment/threateningGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksHate/threateningGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksIllicit/non-violentGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksIllicit/violentGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksNon-violent hateGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksPersonal dataGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksSelf-harm/instructionsGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksSelf-harm/intentGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksSexual/exploitativeGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Production BenchmarksSexual/minorsGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
From other documents
Production BenchmarksEmotional relianceGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksExtremismGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksHarassmentGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksHateGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksIllicit/non-violentGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksIllicit/violentGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksMental healthGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksPersonal dataGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksSelf-harm/instructionsGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksSelf-harm/intentGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksSexualGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksSexual/minorsGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Production BenchmarksViolenceGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported
Cyber safetyProduction dataGPT-5.2 System Card (update to GPT-5 card)11 Dec 2025First reportedGPT-5.2 System Card (update to GPT-5 card)11 Dec 2025First reported
Cyber safetySynthetic dataGPT-5.2 System Card (update to GPT-5 card)11 Dec 2025First reportedGPT-5.2 System Card (update to GPT-5 card)11 Dec 2025First reported

M8 · Jailbreak robustness 5 values

M8 Jailbreak robustness: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
StrongRejectAbuse/disinformation/hateGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
StrongRejectIllicit/non-violent crimeGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
StrongRejectSexual contentGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
StrongRejectViolenceGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
From other documents
StrongRejectnot_unsafe (aggregate)GPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1 Instant and Thinking System Card Addendum12 Nov 2025First reported

M9 · Prompt injection 3 values

M9 Prompt injection: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
Prompt injectionBrowsingGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Prompt injectionCodingGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Prompt injectionTool callingGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

M10 · Dangerous capabilities and risk determinations 15 values

M10 Dangerous capabilities and risk determinations: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
50% time horizonTask length at 50% successRun by METRGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesEasy: challenges solvedCondition: out of 18 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesEvasion: average success rateRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesHard: challenges solvedCondition: out of 4 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesMedium: challenges solvedCondition: out of 14 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesNetwork attack simulation: average success rateRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Cyber challengesVulnerability discovery and exploitation: average success rateRun by IrregularGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
OpenAI-Proof Q&APass rateGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Preparedness Framework determinationAI self-improvementGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Preparedness Framework determinationBiological and chemicalGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
Preparedness Framework determinationCybersecurityGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
TroubleshootingBenchDifference vs o3GPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
From other documents
Cyber challengesEasy: challenges solvedCondition: out of 18 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reported
Cyber challengesHard: challenges solvedCondition: out of 6 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reported
Cyber challengesMedium: challenges solvedCondition: out of 17 challengesRun by IrregularGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reportedGPT-5.1-Codex-Max System Card18 Nov 2025First reported

M12 · Chain-of-thought monitorability 2 values

M12 Chain-of-thought monitorability: values about gpt-5-thinking
Evaluation and metricValueDocument
From its own documentGPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
CoT controllabilityAbility to control CoT contentGPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025
CoT monitorabilityMonitorability vs o3GPT-5 System Card7 Aug 2025

Risk determinations

The developer's formal decisions about gpt-5-thinking under its framework, as printed. Levels from different frameworks do not map onto one another.

Risk determinations about gpt-5-thinking
DomainLevel as printedFramework and document
Bio/chemHigh (precautionary) Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
CyberBelow High Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025
AI R&D / autonomyBelow High Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025Preparedness Framework GPT-5 System Card · 7 Aug 2025